Most cash offers arrive as a single number with no visible arithmetic behind it. That is the wrong shape for an offer, because a number you cannot question is a number you cannot trust. Here is the formula we actually use, what goes into each line, and the questions worth asking any buyer, including us, about the math.
The Formula
Offer = what the property is worth as it sits − the repairs we absorb − holding and transaction costs − margin.
That is the whole structure. Every serious cash buyer runs some version of it; the difference between a trustworthy offer and a lowball is whether the lines are real numbers you can inspect or invented padding you cannot.
Line 1: What the Property Is Worth As It Sits
The starting point is an honest value opinion on the house in its current condition, grounded in comparable sales of similar-condition homes nearby, not the renovated listing three streets over. On a clean retail-ready house this number approaches market value. On a house with a failed roof and 1998 systems it is meaningfully lower, and it should be, because the next lines price exactly that gap.
For multifamily the input changes: the building is underwritten on what it actually earns, the real rent roll against real expenses, not a hypothetical renovated rent. The multifamily page describes that underwriting in more detail.
Line 2: The Repairs We Absorb
This is the line where vague offers hide their padding. Our walkthrough produces a scope, not a vibe: roof, HVAC, kitchen and baths, flooring, paint, exterior, code items, whatever the property actually needs to reach the value in line one. Each item carries a real cost from the trades who do the work, not a round number invented to justify the offer.
You can and should question this line. If we have priced a kitchen that does not need replacing, say so. If your contractor says the roof number is high, show us. The repair scope is the most negotiable line in the formula because it is the most factual one.
Line 3: Holding and Transaction Costs
A buyer who renovates and resells carries the property for months: taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, plus the transaction costs on both ends, including doc stamps on the purchase, the eventual resale's title and listing costs, and the cost of the capital while it sits. On a Broward house that block of costs is a real five-figure number before anyone renovates a thing. The doc stamps post covers one piece of it.
Line 4: The Margin
Yes, there is a margin, and any buyer who pretends otherwise is the one to walk away from. A real-estate business that buys, repairs, holds, and resells earns the spread between what it paid all-in and what the property sells for. The margin is not hidden in our math; it is the last line of it. What makes an offer fair is not the absence of a margin but whether every line above it is honest.
Why the Number Comes Out Below a Listing Price
Listing price and cash-offer price answer different questions. A listing price asks what a retail buyer might pay for the house after repairs, commissions, months of showings, and the risk of a financed deal collapsing. A cash offer answers what the house is worth today, as it sits, with a buyer who absorbs all of that. The gap between them is not profit skimmed off you; it is the cost of the work, time, and risk the buyer takes on. The cash buyers versus market value post puts honest ranges on that gap, and when listing would genuinely net you more we say so, because the cash-offer-versus-listing comparison is a math problem, not a sales pitch.
The Questions to Ask Any Cash Buyer
- What did you estimate the as-is value at, and which comparable sales did you use?
- What repair scope and costs did you subtract, line by line?
- What are your holding and transaction costs?
- Is the entity on the contract the one that closes, or can it assign? On houses we close as principal; on multifamily, the structure is disclosed in writing before you sign.
- Can I take this contract to my attorney or agent before signing? The answer should be yes without hesitation.
The Bottom Line
A cash offer you can trust is a formula with the arithmetic showing, not a number on a postcard. Ours runs value minus repairs minus holding costs minus margin, and every line is a question you are invited to ask. That is what "in writing" is for.
Want the actual numbers on your property? Call or text (650) 540-1854. InTym Properties writes the offer, shows the lines, and the number we sign is the number that closes.